January 18, 2013

  • Hope: The Bane of Happiness

    I have been wondering at my elevated levels of irritation lately. I am, often, a pretty even keeled fellow, even called lethargic at times. I don’t know if you can call me stoic because, really, I have a television in my house, but in regards to intense displays of emotion I am more to that side of things. I have spouts of irritation though, when I was young these flamed me to outright outrage and usually a stretch of black depression. Those days have been tempered, however, and I am not so sensitive. Thus it seems odd that my levels of irritation have lasted for this time. It is only of late that I recognize where it comes from; it comes from a familiar foe but one that I thought I had bested years ago-hope.

    Hope, in our modern age, has arisen to something of a star status. It is at the forefront of what we deem as a proper stance toward the world-hopeful. But, if we look historically it was not always that case, and, if anything, I am throwback in so many ways. When thinking of hope, I like to think about how our western predecessors to this strange experiment we have tried here-the Hellenistic hoards most specifically the Athenians. When they came to do what they do-war and pillage-and call it an honorable vocation, they would often give the defending people an opportunity to give up. To make terms. Usually something along the line of a percentage of their people given up as slaves, women as bed slaves, gold, tribute for a certain amount of time. In exchange the Athenians would not take more in pillage and would wouldn’t kill a large portion of them.

    This offer was given to an island city state. They refused. They replied that despite the overwhelming might of the Athenians they were going to hope for the Lacedonians to send aid. At this meeting, the Athenians replied, “They are not coming and they have not given you any indication that they will come. You are left only with hope. Hope is a pale and weak thing and only arises when one has lost the ability to change their own fate. Hope not. Use your better judgement and don’t send your soldiers to certain death and your city to flames.”

    I have allowed hope to fester in my bones. The hopes for a kinder world, for systems to produce to their stated values, for individuals to understand their power and place in this scope of suffering and its end. There is more but it hurts to gag it up any more. I am filled with such folly, such silliness, filled with such hope. Hope, can only bring about the rending of one’s flesh whether literal in the sense of the foes of the Athenians or symbolically. For, I ask you, what person with an inkling of intelligence has ever received their hopes? Oh, the mundane aspects of meat or mead have been accomplished but those are not really hopes, are they? Hopes are that which has an aspect of impossibility to them and are usually the haunts of creative men and women.

    If I ponder this idea of Hope and where it should be placed within my life, for, try as I might, it will not leave me. It haunts my being like some childhood memory that I wish to forget. I think it is a part of me much like my brain stem or some such. It cannot be removed from my being and thus must be lived with. Where is it that I can place this troublesome, innate aspect of my being, is a thought I am having now.

    Hope, I guess, would have to be placed in the external, a placement put upon that which I have only the ability to name. The indefatigable Other. However, this is not the same joyful placement that many would applaud. I strip this Hope of any expectations, I place this hope in its proper place where it can do little harm, a place where my fantasies of greatness and riding dragons reside. I place it here because of its weakness but I also place it here because of its ubiquity-it never has to leave. One could be hanging from the edge of a cliff by a tuft of grass and hope could arise that a giant eagle would swoop them up. But here, in this closet of desires, it can do little harm and keep me from being overwhelmed with unfulfilled hopes-and from the arrows of Athenians.

    What is left then without hope? One could ask this as a wondering as to how one would motivate themselves into action. Is it not the perfect ideas, or the more perfect ideas, that motivate the inert moment into action? In regards to hope, it can. But if we are to measure one’s happiness as a goal if we use hope as the brass ring to action it will fail miserably. There is something of the flavor of hope that can be used, though. It is expectation. Expectation can be used as both a means of whittling away the fantasies and as a goad to move us beyond inertia.

    An expectation of the self is the internal measure, as hope is the external. Expectation, in its better form, is coupled with honesty to be able to glare into the looking glass and understand what tools one has to work with. An honest assessment of one’s abilities, at a current state, as one can always gain more tools (although there are some innate one’s that are also there as well). In the light of these tools one can have expectations for oneself. Expectations on how to behave in situations that, perhaps, have not occured yet-bravery is often practiced in the heart’s of men and women before they are measured in reality. This measure is, when coupled with honesty, a preparation for the rigors of life.

    I have expectations of myself in this life. To be driven toward my understanding of the good and to stand up for it in the ways that my means allow. The reality that unfolds, in many ways, is not of my doing, its causes were long before I even existed. I have an internal free will to engage an external world.

    Expectations for myself, hope for the world, and in this I can shed my vanity, gain a happiness, glory in what I can do.

    Be well
    G

Comments (3)

  • Once again, my friend, I must apologize for my sporadic communication-- due to my unfortunate ability to squander riches and opportunity, I find myself in rather unstable living conditions once again (though I should have regular internet access for now).

    After the deaths of three close family members in the past two and a half years, I fell into that easy snare of existential "angst" which sometimes plagues the sensitive-- but I probably have already mentioned that before.

    Alas, to your topic here, hope may spring anew. At least, perhaps, I can hope for hope.

    I read your previous entry about a week ago, and was quite amazed. Your talent to convey truly deep and personal thoughts has always been a treat for me to read, no matter the subject-- of agony or ecstasy-- in good mood and foul, your words cut right to the core. Without pretense nor ego in your words, I can see an insight to your "soul" (however brief, however small the view) and appreciate precisely what you are writing about. I go on like this, as it is a rare pleasure for me to know an authentic person, a "true man" (such adulation you may protest, but I am most sincere)-- much like Diogenes and his lantern in daylight, I am vigilant for realness from people.

    I mention your previous entry because it read so beautifully. It stuck with me long afterward, each sentence so smooth like a fine wine of preferable vintage. I am convinced there is an audience for your thoughts beyond cyberspace, onto the written (rather, "traditionally published") word. Knowing your time may be scarce with family matters and your career, I must implore you to squirrel away time to someday put together anything to present to a literary agent. Fiction, autobiographical, poetry-- even just a collection of your monographs from this very blog-- something to leave and enrich the lives of whoever may pick it up. I am very lucky to have met you through xanga, as my life has surely been enriched by reading your blog.

    Enough lauding from me! I don't mean to sound so sanguine about your humble entries here, but I do truly mean every word. Few people can be so consistent with their wisdom, but you have been writing here for seven years and some change-- each entry containing value.

    Back onto your subject at hand here, I agree with your sentiments, almost as if they were my own.

    I'll leave you with some words from Susanna Moodie, which may be appropriate:

    "Hope.— Pandora brought the box with the evils and opened it. It was the gods' gift to man, on the outside a beautiful, enticing gift, called the "box of good fortune." Then all the evils, those lively, winged beings, flew out of it. Since that time, they roam around and do harm to men by day and night. One single evil had not yet slipped out of the box. As Zeus had wished, Pandora slammed the top down and it remained inside. So now man has the box of good fortune in his house forever and thinks the world of the treasure. It is at his service; he reaches for it when he fancies it. For he does not know that the box which Pandora brought was the box of evils, and he takes the remaining evil for the greatest worldly good—it is hope, for Zeus did not want man to throw his life away, no matter how much the other evils might torment him, but rather to go on letting himself be tormented anew. To that end, he gives man hope. In truth, it is the most evil of evils because it prolongs man's torment."

  • @monkegeist -  From you, my friend, any praise is sweet indeed. I don't take it well from many people because I have found that it sound incongruous to my internal examination. I am such a flawed man, deeply flawed, stupid in so many ways, weak and ignorant. I know this not as some false modesty but as an honest, daily, assessment of myself. I fail far more times than I ever succeed. BUT-I can say, I have gotten better. 

    There is a practice that a great Lama did in Tibet that is very simple. In the light of what he considered virtue he measured himself each day. A black stone for a bad deed, a white stone for a good deed, this was his practice before he went to sleep. When he began, the entire pile was black. Slowly, after years, decades, the tide turned, and eventually the pile was all white. My pile is still black as midnight on a new moon. However, even on such a night there are pocks of stars when, for me, before it was only a slate of unbroken pitch. 
    Thank you for your praise. From you, I shall take it, you know, though, it is a very hard pill, for me, to swallow. But thank you. I makes me glad, happy, and determined. 
    I am so sorry about the deaths. It haunts us always, does it not? I am moving to a home after I must renig on my mortgage because my father has fallen ill. He has no money, or anyone to care for him, and thus I have to move him in with my family. I shouldn't say "have to' there is a large part that is glad to do so-but if you know my father, it will not be all an ease. He has been sick for going on 2 years. All his friends stop coming, he is on the verge of homelessness, and has no means. I tell you this to, hopefully, let you know that there is someone that is struggling along too, that care for your struggles, and knows, to a small degree, a level of suffering. I know this and respect and honor what you are going through. A good man is measured in the face of difficult times. In fact, that is the only fires that can temper this steel. 
    You should know, in regards to your comments about writing for publishing-it has been a dream of mine. However, it is an area I am deeply fearful of. I am afraid in my 'art'. It is so close to my heart and thoughts that praise or, embarrassingly, critique would harm me whereas in almost any other aspect of my life-I am not bothered. In this medium I have a few readers and it is mostly anonymous-except for to you-and I can hide. It is shaming to admit that there is an aspect of that, one to be good to my family, one to those that may be harmed by what I write in regards to Tibet, but there is a large part that is using it as a shield. 
    Thank  You my friend. When I move I will have a guest room-come see me. 
    be wellG

  • I am most sorry to hear about your father's condition-- I know you care about him deeply from past entries and conversations; your admiration for him will never wane and I commend you for taking the necessary steps to make his life more comfortable. This past autumn, my brother and I would have to handle our grandmother's final days as her insurance stopped covering her stay at a hospice. We would have to help her with the bathroom, physically lifting her out of bed, into a wheel chair, and unto the toilet. It may be saddening to see a family member, once strong and able, now diminishing. But nothing is more necessary than caring for those who have cared for us.

    I, too, am hard to take praise-- and as an artist, am "allergic to criticism" (as I once heard it phrased)-- so I completely understand your stance on further publishing. I did not previously think of the consequences regarding Tibet and your stances, but now I see and recognize your reason for anonymity-- something I regard as sacred, especially in this modern internet age. I sincerely appreciate what you left as a comment on my blog about publishing, something I hold dear as a dream, and earnestly meant to do when I had the resources to explore. One day I certainly shall, and hopefully toward your description, as a real hand-crafted art, through and through.

    I try to leave my poems open to interpretation, sometimes seeing more or something else than I intended when others respond, but you often cut to exactly what I was thinking when composing-- astonishingly precise on may last one ("The lonely battlefield"). You broke down, line by line, the moment and feelings I meditated upon before writing. How rare, and genuine, is it when mindsets are so synchronized.

    Another thing I hoped for, especially (again) when I had the resources to make it so, was to visit you-- something I am determined to do no matter what, soon enough. I feel and know it would be more than worthwhile to take that trip.

    As for taking stock of virtue versus "sin", this is something I struggle with as well. Like Li Po said in a poem-- "lowering my hat, I remember all my debts and errors." Perhaps we can live with such, as we are only human, but there is virtue in itself in aspiring to be better men.

    I hope you continue to be well, as well as you can try to be.

    thanks,
    --R

Comments are closed.

Post a Comment